Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce: Pros & Cons



Magento is a popular vendor offering an eCommerce platform for launching and managing an online store. This content management system’s strengths include flexibility, power, ease of integration, and scalability. However, once you start exploring its functionality, you may find that there are several editions in one solution. That’s right.

Having got under the Adobe’s patronage, Magento now comes under three names:

●     Magento Open Source;

●     Adobe Commerce;

●     Adobe Commerce Cloud.

These solutions have a common core and a potent eCommerce engine. But there are significant differences.

Magento Open Source is free and has limited functionality, yet it’s still enough to build a successful online store from the ground up. Adobe Commerce is premium and offers more advanced capabilities for B2B and B2C businesses. Adobe Commerce Cloud is essentially the same as Adobe Commerce but hosted in a cloud. So you don’t have to worry about finding a hosting provider.

Are you feeling a little nervous about choosing the right option? Fear not, for in this article, we’ll compare Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce from various perspectives:

●     their pros and cons;

● what businesses each suits best;

●     when you should consider transitioning between them.

Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce: Defining the Platforms

This section makes a comparative discussion on Adobe Commerce and the Magento Open Source.

Magento Open Source: What It Is & Its Core Functionalities

Future Of Magento Open Source

Screenshot taken on the official Adobe website

Magento Open Source, previously known as Magento Community, is a free platform tailored for eCommerce. At its heart, it’s a community-driven project. It grants businesses the freedom to tweak, twist, and turn the platform to fit their unique needs. Out of the box, it boasts features like:

●     product management;

● checkout processes;

●     basic SEO tools.

They all aim to give you a leg up in setting up your online storefront. Here, we discuss the pros and cons of the Magento Open Source.

●     Flexibility: Being open-source, you have the reigns to mold it however you see fit.

Cost-efficient: With no upfront costs, startups and small businesses often lean into Magento for its wallet-friendly nature.

●     Community support: With a vast pool of developers and enthusiasts backing it, you can find solutions to potential problems by communicating on a forum.

●  Requires technical know-how: With great flexibility comes the need for specialized experience. It’s not a platform to click “Install” and plunge into selling. To harness its full potential, you’d ideally need some web development skills or a team of dedicated specialists like Onilab.

Performance: It depends on the hosting type you purchase. Some startups, trying to save on initial investment, opt for shared hosting platforms. But due to this, Magento can sometimes come off as sluggish. Dedicated hosting or optimization is key.

●     Complexity: Its rich features can be overwhelming for newcomers, and there’s a steeper learning curve involved.

Adobe Commerce (formerly Magento Enterprise)

Adobe Commerce

Screenshot taken on the official Adobe website

Adobe Commerce emerged from the roots of Magento, evolving into a more refined, cloud-based solution. Adobe saw the potential in Magento and, after acquiring it, blended in its expertise to offer an advanced eCommerce solution. It’s Magento under the hood but with greater capabilities, paired with Adobe’s suite of tools.

●  Integration with Adobe Suite: Pairing with tools like Adobe Analytics and Experience Manager can supercharge your marketing and analysis efforts.

Enhanced performance: Speed and responsiveness are given a boost, improving user experience.

Dedicated support: Unlike its open-source counterpart, Adobe Commerce offers official support, paving a smoother road for businesses.

Extra benefit: If you purchase a cloud-based version, you can leverage the company infrastructure for automatic updates, better security, and seamless scalability.

Cons of Adobe Commerce

●     Pricey: Superior features imply a heftier price tag, which might not sit well with smaller companies.

●     Excessive features: Small and medium businesses may not need all the possibilities offered in the package. Configuring and installing them involves more technical and financial headaches you may avoid when choosing the open-source version.

Comparing the Features of Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce

Recent statistics show that Magento increased its sales share from 2.32% in previous years to 8% in 2021. Let’s see why online merchants favor this platform and how its editions differ in terms of features.

Core Features & Functionalities

Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce
Open SourceCommerce
Ready-to-use features, including:
●     catalog management;
●     site search;
●     WYSIWYG page builder;
●     checkout, payment, and delivery integration;
●     instant purchase;
●     global selling;
●     marketing and SEO tools;
●     the ability to install extensions from Adobe Commerce (Magento) Marketplace.
The same as in Open Source + the following:
●     AI-powered functionality;
●     business intelligence dashboards;
●     B2B functionality;
●     advanced marketing tools;
●     staging id content  and preview;
●     Tools on Customer loyalty;
●     visual merchandising;
●     return management authorization;
●     configurable order tracking widget.
Mobile commerce capabilities, such as responsive themes and templates.A more seamless mobile shopping experience.
Doesn’t integrate with the Adobe Suite but is still compatible with various third-party services and extensions.Integration into the Adobe Suite, including products like Adobe Experience Manager, Target, Analytics, etc.

Performance & Scalability

Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce
Open SourceCommerce
No tools for improving performance, but you can install corresponding innovative Magento 2 extensions.●     Performance monitoring tools;
●     fast page loading with CDN.
Ideal for budding ventures.Excels in accommodating traffic surges.

Customization & Extensibility

Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce
Open SourceCommerce
A vast array of extensions due to its open-source nature.Integrations with enterprise-grade tools.
Managing several stores from a single backend.The same as in Magento Open Source + paves the way for multi-channel commerce.

Cost Analysis

Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce
Open SourceCommerce
Free, but costs can increase with customization.From $22,000.00 to $125,000.00, depending on the expected annual gross sales revenue.

Security & Support

Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce
Isn’t PCI compliant.●     PCI compliance;
●     credit card tokenization;
●     bug bounty programs;
●     external penetration testing;
●     enhanced payment security;
●     web application firewall.
Support from the community on forums, open documentation, blogs, etc.Official support from Adobe.

Marketing & Engagement Tools

Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce
Open SourceCommerce
Basic but robust SEO tools.●     Sharper segmentation and personalization;
●     integration with Google Tag Manager;
●     automation;
●     flexible pricing;
●     in-depth marketing reports;
●     the ability to preview and schedule content and revert the changes.


Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce
Open SourceCommerce
It’s faster to set up than Adobe Commerce. Note that, in any case, it entails much more coding and effort compared to SaaS solutions like Shopify, for example.Nevertheless, Magento Open Source allows for rapid deployment as you don’t need to install a more sophisticated toolset of Adobe Commerce.Launching a website on Adobe Commerce involves a little more work because the toolset is more advanced. Expect a longer deployment period, especially if you plan to use all its features. But this comprehensive setup ensures a powerful and reliable online store.

Who Should Use Which? Managing Your Business from the Right Platform

Now let’s overview different types of businesses and what edition they should choose according to their peculiarities.

Startups & New Entrepreneurs

One of the biggest concerns for eCommerce beginners is money. As Magento Open Source is free, it becomes a common weapon of choice for individuals running on a shoestring budget. But you shouldn’t fall for the cost-saving aspect alone.

The platform’s open-source nature provides an excellent playground for experimenting, testing, and figuring out what works best. So, if you’re ready to bring in a developer, you’ll be able to start and grow the company without purchasing a high-cost license.

SMBs (Small and Medium-sized Businesses)

That’s where some hesitation may arise. SMBs frequently strive to strike a balance between growth and costs. Choose one over another, and you risk lagging behind the competition or falling into a debt pit.

Magento Open Source still remains a strong candidate due to its customizability. But Adobe Commerce starts to shine here, particularly for businesses anticipating rapid expansion. For those heavily into scalability, Adobe Commerce provides cloud-based infrastructure. Plus, it comes with marketing and analytics tools for the following tasks:

●     advanced targeting and segmentation;

●     advanced content management;

●     customizable loyalty programs and rewards.

Large Enterprises

Are you a big market player? Then, the choice should fall on Adobe Commerce. Businesses at this scale require resilience, first-rate security, and smooth interfaces packaged in a high-performance solution. Adobe Commerce provides exactly that.

Large organizations can take advantage of its cutting-edge features, rely on official support, and combine it with other enterprise-level applications. Although the initial outlay may be considerable, the performance, security, and scalability benefits will pay off.

Transitioning Between Platforms

When considering Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce, you don’t have to decide on one option once and for all. It’s okay to change your mind and switch to another solution. Yet, it’s a demanding task, and you should think about it only if your situation meets certain criteria.

For example, the store starts to expand and attract more visitors. Or you’re consistently updating software to meet new demands, add new extensions, and integrate more services built in Adobe Commerce out of the box.

All of this may slow down your Magento site. One more reason to invest in Adobe Commerce is to access features like detailed customer insights or cross-channel selling.

Once you’ve decided to migrate, you can’t transfer data alone. Some more steps include:

●     ensuring module compatibility;

● redesigning user interfaces;

●     retraining staff.

So, again, hiring Magento developers may be inevitable. Specialists will take care of not only the technical side of the transformation but also ensure a smooth customer experience throughout the process. The result? Retaining essential features and keeping your audience engaged.

Final Thoughts

So what should you pick: Magento Open Source vs. Adobe Commerce? The answer boils down to your business goals and readiness to invest in the platform’s capabilities. Magento Open Source is a reliable and flexible foundation for bringing your store into existence. Adobe Commerce, in turn, is your trusted ally when your ambitions and operations scale.

Remember that developing an effective store goes beyond the platform itself. It also covers design, testing, collecting and acting upon user feedback. So, plan diligently and use the chosen CMS to its fullest potential.

Read Also:

author image

Shahnawaz is a passionate and professional Content writer. He loves to read, write, draw and share his knowledge in different niches like Technology, Cryptocurrency, Travel,Social Media, Social Media Marketing, and Healthcare.